Will Your Insurance Still Cover Your Roof at 15 Years?

An Iowa roofer on the new FORTIFIED rule, ACV roof payouts and what the 2020 derecho taught us.

Prefer to watch? I walk through this whole post in the 6-minute video above, or watch it on YouTube.

Will your insurance still cover your roof at 15 years? That’s the question I’m hearing from Iowa homeowners, and it got sharper this fall.

In September, the insurance industry’s own storm research group set a 15-year limit for asphalt shingle roofs in its FORTIFIED program. On paper, it’s a rule about one designation program. It doesn’t say your roof is worn out at 15, and it doesn’t tell your insurance company what to do.

But I’ve been on a lot of Iowa roofs and through a lot of Iowa claims, and I believe this rule will reach Iowa insurance policies. I’ll explain why below, and I’ll keep my prediction clearly separate from what’s on the record.

Three different promises protect your house, and they don’t measure the same thing:

  • What your insurance policy pays when a storm hits.
  • What the manufacturer’s warranty covers.
  • How your roof was actually built.

Here’s how each one works, what I see when my crews tear off 15- and 20-year-old roofs, what the 2020 derecho taught us about installation, and the one thing I’d ask every Iowa homeowner to do before the next storm.

What IBHS actually changed

The Insurance Institute for Business & Home Safety (IBHS) runs a program called FORTIFIED. It’s a voluntary, beyond-code standard for building a roof that holds up in high wind. A certified evaluator checks the work, and IBHS issues a designation for a set term.

On September 29, 2026, IBHS released Technical Bulletin FH 2026-03. For applications filed on or after January 1, 2027, homes with asphalt shingles can only hold a FORTIFIED designation for up to 15 years:

  • New FORTIFIED roof: 15 years from the first designation date.
  • Existing roof with a documented install date: 15 years from that install date.
  • Existing roof with no documented install date: one term of up to 5 years, then no redesignation until the shingles are replaced.
  • Designations issued before 2027: not shortened.

IBHS says plainly that the rule does not set how long shingles last, does not judge whether your roof is still fit to use, and does not require replacement for any reason other than FORTIFIED eligibility.

The research behind it found that most shingles gained wind resistance in their first few years, then lost some between years 5 and 10. The biggest reason was shingles coming unsealed. Products with the same top wind rating aged very differently. The roofing manufacturers’ trade group, ARMA, disputes the testing methods and the sample size, and points out that some of the 10-year samples held or even gained strength.

Here’s the part Iowa homeowners should know: the bulletin cites a roof-age study from Cedar Rapids and research on the 2020 Midwest derecho. This rule was built partly on Iowa roofs.

What I see when we tear off a 15- or 20-year-old Iowa roof

I think both sides of this fight have a point. Shingles do age differently. But from where I stand on the roof, installation is the real story. A bad install fails long before 15 years.

When my crews strip an older roof in Iowa, here’s what we find most often:

  • Tabs that have come unsealed and are lifting. That matches what IBHS found.
  • Installation shortcuts. Nails set too high, too few nails, staples instead of nails, no ice and water barrier, and poor flashing.

In a lot of those cases the shingle didn’t fail. The install did.

And here’s the other side of it: plenty of 15- to 20-year-old roofs we look at are still sound. Age alone doesn’t tell you if your roof is done. Somebody has to get up there and look.

What “lifetime” really means

“Lifetime” on a shingle wrapper is a contract term, and it usually means as long as you own the home. It is not a promise that your roof survives every storm for life. And not every “lifetime” warranty is the same contract.

Our standard re-roof is Owens Corning Duration shingles installed as a full Owens Corning system. Here’s how the basic shingle warranty compares to the Platinum Protection system warranty that only an Owens Corning Platinum Preferred contractor can register, per Owens Corning’s own warranty comparison:

Standard product warranty Platinum Protection system warranty
Full coverage for manufacturing defects (materials and labor) First 10 years First 50 years
After that Materials only, prorated Materials only
Blow-off (wind) coverage First 15 years First 15 years
Workmanship (installation) coverage None Limited lifetime, reduced after 25 years based on roof age
Who can offer it Any installer Platinum Preferred contractor, using Owens Corning system components
Transfer One time, within 60 days of the home sale One time, within 60 days of the home sale

Two things jump out to me. First, the wind coverage is 15 years on both. A better warranty doesn’t stretch the blow-off period. Second, the big difference is who stands behind the installation. On a standard warranty, if the roof fails because it was put on wrong, that’s on the contractor, if they’re still in business.

And hail? Owens Corning’s Duration brochure says hail damage is excluded. That’s what your homeowners insurance is for.

What the 2020 derecho taught us: the shingles held, the decking didn’t

On August 10, 2020, the derecho tore across Iowa. We had customers with Owens Corning Duration roofs we’d installed, which carried a 130 mph wind warranty at the time. We didn’t lose shingles. What our customers lost was whole sheets of OSB decking, ripped off the house with the Duration shingles still nailed to them.

Today, Owens Corning’s current warranty terms take Duration up to a 160 mph wind warranty when the required Owens Corning components are used and starter shingles go on both the eaves and rakes, the way we install for Platinum Protection. But the derecho taught us that a higher wind rating on the shingle only goes so far.

That changed how I think about roofs. The shingle is only as good as what it’s nailed to. Our conclusion from the derecho: fasten the decking with ring-shank nails. Ring-shank nails have rings along the shaft that grip the wood, so they resist pulling out far better than smooth nails.

Here’s what’s standard in Iowa today versus what’s an upgrade:

  • Industry standard in Iowa: replace any deck material that’s damaged and refasten any loose deck. Depending on the contractor, replacing a sheet of plywood runs about $50 to $120 per sheet.
  • Our standard: ice and water barrier at the eaves and valleys.
  • Upgrades: extra deck nailing with ring-shank nails, and a fully sealed roof deck.

For comparison, FORTIFIED is much stricter. The 2025 FORTIFIED standard calls for re-nailing the deck with 8d ring-shank nails no more than 4 inches apart, per an Oklahoma Insurance Department FORTIFIED scope of work. It also requires a sealed roof deck, like tape over every seam in the decking under the underlayment.

Why does a sealed deck matter? If the wind strips your shingles, the deck is all that’s left between the rain and your ceiling. IBHS testing found a sealed roof deck can cut water coming into the home by as much as 95% compared to a bare, unsealed deck.

To be clear, Superstorm is not a certified FORTIFIED contractor today. We’re looking into it. But you don’t need a certificate to ask your roofer how the deck will be fastened and whether it’ll be sealed.

Class 4 isn’t the whole hail story

Iowa gets hammered by hail, and the derecho showed us what wind can do. Both shape how we build and what we tell homeowners.

You’ll hear a lot about “Class 4” shingles. That rating comes from a lab test where a steel ball is dropped on the shingle. It’s useful, but it’s not the only test.

IBHS runs its own hail ratings using lab-made hailstones instead of steel balls. In its 2025 ratings, most impact-resistant shingles rated “Good,” none rated “Excellent,” and some rated only “Marginal.” So a shingle sold as impact-resistant doesn’t automatically hold up well in IBHS testing. For a FORTIFIED Hail designation, the shingle must rate Good or Excellent on IBHS’s current list, per a FORTIFIED product advisory. Class 4 alone doesn’t qualify.

Then there’s the insurance side, and this is where I tell homeowners to watch the strings. An impact-resistant discount often comes with a cosmetic-damage exclusion. Even GAF, one of the biggest shingle makers, warns that carriers may require a cosmetic waiver endorsement to get the discount. That means if hail dents your roof but doesn’t break it, the claim may not be paid. A small yearly savings can cost you a roof at claim time.

Before you choose a shingle for the discount, get it in writing from your agent: what the discount is, and what you give up for it. (More on this in our guide to impact-resistant shingles.)

The part that matters most in Iowa: your policy’s roof terms

FORTIFIED is still new in Iowa. Your insurance policy is where I think this rule ends up mattering.

Most property owners don’t understand their policies. Unfortunately, most find out what their coverage actually is after they’ve filed a claim. On older roofs, here’s what my customers run into most:

  • Actual cash value (ACV) and depreciation. The claim check covers what the roof was worth after its age is figured in, not what a new one costs.
  • Roof payment schedules. A table in your policy that pays a set percentage of the roof cost based on its age and material.
  • Non-renewal because of roof age.
  • Cosmetic-damage exclusions that come with impact-resistant discounts.

This isn’t a rare thing. A 2024 Des Moines Register review of filings from Iowa’s 10 largest property insurers found all 10 had changed their roof coverage since 2020. Seven started paying for roofs at a depreciated value. The Iowa Insurance Division warns that a roof endorsement may replace replacement cost coverage with actual cash value, and may set depreciation based on the age and type of roofing.

And premiums keep climbing. Insurify reported Iowa’s average home insurance premium rose 28% in 2025, to about $2,802 a year.

Here’s what a roof payment schedule looks like in real life. This is from Farm Bureau Financial Services’ published sample schedule for dwellings, effective July 23, 2026 in Iowa. It shows the share of the roof cost paid on a covered wind or hail loss:

Roof age Class 3 or 4 impact-resistant Standard shingles
5 years 92% 90%
10 years 82% 80%
15 years 72% 70%
20 years 60.5% 60%
25 years 50% 50%
30 years 40% 40%
35+ years 40% 25%

Put real dollars on that. On a 15-year-old roof with standard shingles, a $10,000 roof pays about $7,000, and then your deductible comes out of that.

Farm Bureau’s sheet also says roofs 15 years or newer may qualify for 100% replacement cost coverage, and longtime customers may qualify for a Roof Loyalty Benefit, both subject to the policy’s terms. I’m not picking on Farm Bureau. They publish their schedule, and many insurers only put theirs in the policy documents. Your policy may work very differently.

So here’s the one thing I’d ask every Iowa homeowner to do: sit down with your insurance agent and find out how your roof claim will be paid, before a storm, not after. Is it replacement cost, actual cash value, or a roof-age payment schedule? Is there a cosmetic-damage exclusion? That conversation belongs to you and your agent. We’re roofers, not insurance agents, and we don’t review policies. We don’t want to be your agent. We want to be your roofing and siding expert.

My view from the field: I believe this rule will reach Iowa insurance

This section is my prediction and my experience as a contractor. It is not a verified fact.

I believe this ruling will affect Iowa. I think insurance carriers will use it as a basis to stop insuring roofs after 15 years. In my experience, most carriers already switch roofs to actual cash value around year 9 or 10. I think the next step is to stop insuring them at year 15.

I’m not the only one worried about this. The roofing manufacturers who disagree with IBHS on the science share the same concern.

What’s on the record in Iowa

To be clear, I’m not aware of any Iowa carrier that has adopted a 15-year cutoff because of this rule. Here’s what is documented:

Who What’s documented Source
Farm Bureau Financial Services Pays roof claims by a published age schedule. Roofs 15 years or newer may qualify for 100% replacement cost. Customers with 10+ years of property coverage may qualify for a Roof Loyalty Benefit on older roofs. Farm Bureau roof payment schedule
IMT Insurance Reported in 2024 to use actual cash value for all roofs 6 years or older, after applying it only to roofs 16 or older a year earlier. Des Moines Register via United Policyholders
State Farm Introduced a roof payment schedule in 2020 that pays a smaller share of a new roof’s cost as the old roof ages. Offered at the customer’s choice in exchange for a lower premium. Des Moines Register via United Policyholders
Nationwide Reported in 2024 to require a roof payment schedule for shingle roofs at least 11 years old. Des Moines Register via United Policyholders
Iowa Insurance Division Warns that a roof endorsement may replace replacement cost coverage with actual cash value and set depreciation by roof age and type. Iowa Insurance Division
ARMA (shingle manufacturers’ trade group) Urging carriers not to use the new FORTIFIED bulletin to justify broad underwriting restrictions. Claims Journal, Nov. 10, 2026

The IMT, State Farm and Nationwide items come from 2024 reporting, so their terms may have changed since. Check your own policy.

There’s precedent for this kind of thing. In Florida, enough carriers dropped older roofs that lawmakers passed a law in 2022. It stops insurers from non-renewing a policy solely because of roof age when the roof is under 15 years old.

That’s why I keep coming back to the same advice: know how your roof claim will be paid now, before a storm forces the question.

Questions worth asking before you sign for a new roof

Whether you’re getting bids from us or anybody else, these are fair questions:

  1. What exact shingle is going on my roof? Is it Class 3 or Class 4, and how does it rate on the IBHS hail list?
  2. How will the deck be fastened? Will loose decking be refastened, and are ring-shank nails an option?
  3. Is ice and water barrier going in the eaves and valleys? Is a sealed deck an option?
  4. Which warranty am I actually getting? How many years of full material and labor coverage, and who covers the installation?
  5. Will I get dated paperwork? The install date, product names, invoice and photos. Your insurer and the next buyer of your house may both ask for them.

And ask your insurance agent the other half: how your roof claim will be paid, and what any discount costs you in coverage.

The new 15-year rule doesn’t mean your roof is done at 15. But I believe it gives insurance companies one more reason to treat a 15-year-old roof like it is. So know how your policy pays on your roof today. And build the roof right, because the derecho proved that how a roof is installed matters more than the label on the bundle.

Want a second set of eyes on your roof?

Superstorm Roofing & Siding offers free roof inspections with an HD photo report you keep. Schedule your free roof inspection or call (515) 225-4880. We answer 24/7.

Sources

author avatar
Chandler Steffy